Rachel

I was exposed to anime as a child while living in Germany after watching the Japanese version of Hans Christian Anderson’s the Little Mermaid. In high school, a classmate in art brought in Akira as an example of Japanese art. I wasn’t very impressed with anime at the time, but my re-exposure to it in 2000 thanks to Escaflowne had me hooked for life.After sorting out what I liked about anime (great stories, beautiful animation and epic battles) and disliked about anime (big boobs, angst-y 15 year-old kids, most mecha, sports stories and style-over-substance), I got into it with a vengeance.I do love almost all aspects of Japanese culture and try to be involved with it as much as possible. I have no problem admitting that I incorporate a lot of Japanese trends and traditions into my life as I modify them and make them my own. Anime is a big part of that, along with all the sub-cultures, past and present.

11 Comments

  1. Allisha

    I think you are wrong. The novels are very well written and translated, maybe you just prefer uninspired, repetitive visuals over substance. Perhaps instead of complaining about the “hard to read book” you might instead pull out a dictionary. And you’re inability to connect is, I am to conclude, your lack of imagination. I suggest you take a look at current events, many mutations already exist in examples such as humans ironically enough. “Out there instances” such as Cyber horses? Did a mechanical bull not come to mind? Why not build from there? I think you might have walked into the fad idea that is; character development is the only thing that makes a work good, I insist you sit down and think of the vast world that has been meticulasly layed out for you.Could it be you had a hard time “getting into the book” because it actually followed a believable time-line, where, for lack of a more fitting term, MOE cliches of things happening right on time one after the other were not present. I, of course, have seen that time-bewitching “trick” (Performed of course by the scientifically-advanced vampiric nobility)at my local pub once and once again. When you mention the fan service (which I can determine is common, by the D and Doris picture above, in the ‘purdy’ manga) I was a bit baffled, needle in a haysack if I do say so myself, between all the action and stimulation of imagination it was a welcomed break. Umm please don’t relate manga to Amano Yoshitaka’s work, his is lissome and flows, where as manga follows a very definite and easy to do order(circle for the head, 3 lines indicating where giant eyes, tiny triangle nose and straight line mouth belong). His work most certainly has left the restrictive and childish relm of “beautifuly illustrated manga” which I consider to be an oxymoron, but i digress. The paragraphs where you seem praise Saiko’s style and downplay Amano’s is quite shocking to me, ah well to each their own. In closing I would just like to suggest that next time you crack open a book leave the confirmation bias on the shelf.

    -Allisha

  2. Allisha

    Hum. The irony of you suggesting the sentence structure and word use was “horrible” and following with that exact mistake was not lost on me. Also, do you consider manga and it’s over use of the ellipsis more structured with stronger affects than a novel? As a last, you quoting and mocking things I’ve quoted and mocked from you seems a bit asinine.Your little blurb about believing in it is, I believe, incorrectly worded. So you believe in vampires but the idea of time not following a direct line is absurd? Perhaps you should delve into the world of quantum physics where the theory of 20 years being equivalent to 60 years is mathmatically explained.

    The comment you made about my conclusion that you downplayed Amano’s work would come from “…Saiko Takaki did a wonderful job in following and developing Amanao’s initial direction of the character designs”. I assume you know the manga came after the movie, which, came after the novel and that Amano had a direct role in developing the character’s designs in both the novel and movie. Please atleast google something before you start making assumptions, that also refers the to the comment about Amano doing illustrations(which seemingly implies that is all he does). Though he has done that, it is most certainly not his only trade.

    Instead of looking up ‘Hypnosis’ in a dictionary try looking up ‘restrictive’ and ‘childish’ then you won’t be left with the dim-witted remark “huh? What’s that even mean?” Not to suggest that I believe that manga is not art, lets explore the fact that people who draw “art” are called artists and people who draw manga are “mangaka”, could there be reason behind this? Oh and manga is illustration, geez. Lastly I did not suggest that you preferred style over substance, I implied you liked “purdy” over style and substance.

    In closing, I’d like to tell you that I did not insult your lack of imagination I merely connected that with your apparent inability to “believe” the fiction novel. But, as I stated above, to each their own.

  3. Allisha

    Well I’m glad you’re going to stop arguing with me because your defense is somewhat lacking to say the least. I didn’t insult you. I never suggested I was a “loyal fan”. There was nothing to digest, it was a very shallow review. It seemed from the beginning you had no interest in what I had to say, you just made presumptions and denied things I had stated instead of “digesting” them and maybe coming up with a decent justification for what you found to be the case in the novel and manga. Instead you opted for a hackneyed, what I so graciously call, defense. You used sarcasm (the lowest form of wit) as a remark, and didn’t even try to understand what I had said. I think the next time you write a review you should remember to add; I did no research into whom I am speak about and began reading with an apparent bias.

    That would be much appreciated @(?)Rachel.

  4. Halfkoreanmike

    To get so fundamental over a review that is probably face value at best, is a bit funny. There’s no need to debate a opinion laden review, as everyone is different in their likings and taste. I will say that upon reading the review I felt Rachel is more of an appreciator of the visual side of vampire D and Allisha you are probably more in tuned with the broader aspects Vampire hunter D has to offer, like the crafting of a different world with words. I wish I could read a novel or two, and take a peek as to how the transition from Japanese to English is like. I honestly wish someone picked up on making a short vampire hunter D series, or maybe even a movie for every novel. I think it would do both the novels and the manga some justice. Btw who is the artist for the bloodlust film? I feel like the same person who drew bloodlust also drew works like Ninja scroll and a older Black-Jack movie. Also some shorts on Animatrix and Batman: Gotham Knight.

  5. Lynsea

    hhhmmmm…you know, Holloween is coming up, and I was thinking about buying this manga in celebration. (lol) but how far ‘naked’ does Doris go? i mean…it doesn’t show the ‘front bum,’ does it? (sorry, i don’t mean to be immature, but i don’t know what to call it.;)) i mean, if the manga is that amazing, i’ll go ahead and buy it, but i just want to know what i’m getting myself into first. haha

  6. metalmaggot

    As much as I love the Vampire Hunter D series, I do have to admit the elongated descriptions of the scenery & how the characters look can get a little annoying at times. Otherwise, I have no problems with the novels. <3 But that little annoyance is what makes me cling to the manga. It makes 3 to 4 pages of descriptive scenary into one page of beauty. *_* Thanks for reviewing the manga. :D

One Trackback/Pingback

  1. demon language translate

    [...] writer, Hideyuki Kikuchi. Hideyuki first began writing the Vampire Hunter D series in 1983. Yoshttp://theanimeblog.com/2007/12/31/manga-review-vampire-hunter-d-volume-one/HalloweseThis language was one of those props. It was created for the person playing the demon [...]

Leave a Reply

Join The Anime Blog on Twitter!
Join The Anime Blog's Facebook Page

The Anime Blog Sponsors

Would you like to highlight your company's goods and services on our website? Advertise With Us!

Would you like to donate to TheAnimeBlog.com? Your contributions go towards keeping our site up and running! Payments are secure through Paypal:


Categories

Twitter Updates

Performance Optimization WordPress Plugins by W3 EDGE