Ok, so who totally flipped out over last week’s release of the “final” installment of Harry Potter, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows? Who waited in line and who got frisky when they finally had Harry Potter’s last soirée with Voldy in their hands? I ordered mine through Amazon so I didn’t wait in line but I did indeed get frisky when I cracked the spine on this bad boy.
Manga Harry Potter, Hermione Granger and Ron Weasley by yuina19
I finished DH in 8.45 hours and, wow, just wow. I simply cannot wait to see this book on the big screen! Merlin’s Beard, I’m so stoked! I also saw Order of the Phoenix this past Saturday and once again, wow.
But, you know, a lot of stuff got left out of the last movie. And that’s understandable since lordee knows, the books are frick’n epic. Fortunately, I have a solution for this dilemma; Harry Potter manga!
It’s a great idea and, there’s precedent for it in the way of Star Wars manga, Wizard of Oz manga, and even a sequel manga to Labyrinth. These are all well-loved American films that have a sizable fan base and cult-followings; just like Harry Potter.
If HP gets made into a manga, fans’ll get more fleshed out visuals than the movies (though the movies are brilliant) and we’ll get to see our fave HP characters manga-ized.
On my favorite artist community, deviantART, there’s a ton of manga style fan-art of the Harry Potter crew. Especially of the bad boys of the series; Lucius, Draco, and everyone’s fave troubled-soul poster-child, Snape.
There’s even disturbing/ hilarious HP yaoi of DracoxHarry and SnapexLucius. HP chibis also abound on DA. In my opinion, HP has already taken its first step down the manga path.
Chibi Severus Snape: A possible candidate for the Harry Potter Manga?
So after deciding that HP manga is indeed a good idea, I began to ponder who should actually draw the manga. One possibility that came to mind was CLAMP. It’s a good idea, and yet, a bad idea. Good in the sense that CLAMP has a fan-following and people will read it because they’re fans of CLAMP and like their style. However, CLAMP also has a reputation for it’s shoujo style and that might turn off potential readers. That would be the bad part.
I think that an artistic style that’s neither shoujo nor shonen is the way to go for a Harry Potter manga. A style that’s too soft might only attract women and turn off male readers. A style that’s too shonen wouldn’t even fit into the HP’s style. A happy balance of the two would be a great comprise.
Also, I think a HP manga will kill two birds with one stone in terms of satiating the fan-girl’s demand for more Harry/ Draco/ Snape/ Lucius/ whoever and have them done in their fave bishie style (I fear for Lucius however; how much more femme can that guy get and still be a dude? Let’s face it, bishie-fy him and he’s a chick).
All around I think a Harry Potter manga is a smashing idea. Who else thinks so? Are you a fan of merging HP and manga? Who else wants Harry Potter manga?!
*Harry Potter Group is property of yuina19
**Chibi Severus Snape property of auroreblackcat
I’d buy it!
I’d buy it too. That would be amazingly awesome.
I would definitely say hell no for CLAMP. As good as their stuff is, they make guys way too girly, and that would totally ruin HP.
lol If its a manga thats the only way I’d read it lol
As much as I like Harry Potter, I wouldn’t buy a manga of it. Especially not one made by CLAMP.
I’d… well download it.
I think Hiromu Arakawa (Manga-ka of Fullmetal Alchemist) would be good.
Nice art, not too flowery to scare off boys, good sense of humour, liked by both boys and girls.
CLAMP would put major yaoi undertones XD
@Kidan, yeah so would I!
@DKong, I really don’t like CLAMP’s style, but I threw it out there since they’re a well known manga group who fangirls luv. I mean, imagine being J.K. Rowling and someone says, “Hey, we wanna make a manga outta your books!” She’d be like, “WTF, manga, huh?”
@Zack, if you’re interested in the books but don’t have the time to read 700 pages of HP awesomeness, they have the books on CD. I recommend them for busy people. That’s the only way a friend of mine caught up to book 7. Otherwise, I’d still be asking him to leave the room while we discussed HP. But a manga would be additional goodness! I wants me more goodness now that the series is “over”!
@griever, you make baby Harry Potter cry by not wanting to buy HP manga T_T.
@Sen, mmm, yeah, I wouldn’t want CLAMP doing it, but I could understand if someone in J.K’s staff wanted them to ($$$$) Geez, no more HP yaoi, it’s scary enough as fanart let alone in a full fledged manga….
Harry Potter manga would be awesome. (As well as an anime x3). I’d totally buy it if it was published. The debated as too who should make it… I think Arakawa-sensei would be a good idea, or… (I’m trying to think of another artist I know of that draws in-between shounen and shoujo) the guy who draws Azumanga Daioh? (Yeah, shoot me, I forgot his name ;-;)
That would be Great i’d buy it, only one problem; they all ready have some. maybe have 5 of them from what i heard.
@Digichan, finding the right manga-ka for the job would probably be the toughest decision in getting the manga made and published. Arakawa would be an interesting choice.
@sharon, I don’t think that there are any officially licensed HP manga out yet. However, there are quite a few Harry Potter doujinshi. The titles and descriptions can be viewed at Addiction; a Harry Potter Doujinshi website.
I so buy the harry potter mangas.
lol so theres actually a harry potter manga its like japan knows me lol i love harry potter and manga and they mix it up well there goes this month money
but if it seems very diffrent from the book im tottaly retuning it
@Konata_Izumi, there isn’t a Harry Potter manga released yet; this was a post to ask whether or not readers would buy an HP manga if it was released. Sorry to let you down ^^.
I think HP manga would be a great idea! I’d buy it as soon as it would come out. =)
HP+Manga=*sigh*
i love the idea!!!!! i acutually met DAniel Radcliffe!!!! he would look SOOOOO good as manga *sigh*
@Angela, maybe we should petition for HP manga! If we start now, we can have Volume One in time for Christmas next year, lol.
@Ashley, you know, Danny boy is no longer jailbait! Whoohooo! Is he a cutey in person?
J.K. Rowling also helped an HP manga cause this past month by releasing info that Dumbledore was g-a-y. Is a yaoi HP manga far off? (Geez, now all those crappy Dumbledore fanfics, yaoi and slash doujinshi will feel vindicted. Pffttt.)
That snape one is pretty sick. I toatally love it. well done! >.<
haha. dude i would totally buy it!!!!!! that would be so frikin AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ITS BLOODY BRILLIANT !!!!!!
I BOTH ♥ ANIME AND HARRY POTTER SERIES..
ITS ALMOST LIKE PEANUT BUTTER AND JELLY SANDWICH..
PEANUT BUTTER — HARRY POTTER
+ JELLY ———- ANIME
= PB&J SANDWICH!– A GREAT, NEW HIT ANIME THAT WOULD CONQUER THE WORLD!!!!! MWHAHAHAHAHAHA(evil laugh)
Just kidding around…
I JUST SIMPLY SAY KEEP IT UP AND WORK ON IT!!
GOOD LUCK AND GODSPEED…
HP manga is a brilliant idea!
it’d definitely be worth buying!
tho i’d suggest some awesomely talented artist/artists should make it…& the question is who?
OMG!!!!
A Harry Potter manga would be the best thing ever!!
I would totally buy it. I think that they should release some
Marauder era stuff too though.
I’ve always been really interested in that!!!!
~MelMel-chan
Yes. This would be awesome! However, you’d have to be REALLY careful with it. If you mess up on a character design, or even how scenes are drawn out, you could make something aweful. You’d need an expirienced artist. Whoever did Ruroni Kenshin, which in many ways have a similar feel to it. If katanas were wands…
I wish just by us posting this, it would just happen. Tomarrow I google it and find EXACTLY what I want… ;(
I so want harry potter manga i would die if i got it
Wow..! I would definitely buy Harry Potter Manga!
Harry Potter rocks anyway..but manga would be amazing!
I think that the character designs should be done by Kosuke Fujishima, who is known for the character designs for Tales of Phantasia.
@ flashn00b:
Yesh, Fujishima-sensei is an awesome artist!! x3 ^.^ It’d be awesome if he did the art for a HP manga 8D
They should get the guy who did Hellsing to do it.
Harry Potter is a really, really dark story if you look deep enough.
Hey, do want XD Koge-Donbo (the person who did Di-gi-charat) even did some fanarts, but their style is too shoujo. Kia Asamiya is well known by doing manga versions of ocidental medias, like Batman or X-Men, and also did shoujos like Corrector Yui, if he would make a manga of Harry Potter, it could be awesome. Really.
I would totally buy the manga! After I finished the 7th book I felt such a loss at the end! But I think Natsuki Takaya (creator of Fruits Basket (absolutely brilliant)) would be perfect to draw it! If you’ve read Fruits Basket I think it has the perfect balance of Shouji and Shonen. just putting that out there.
@Everyone, seems like we’re all on board with idea of HP manga. Would you prefer the manga follow the story or uncover new ground?
If it would be different stories I think it should have a different name like “Harry Potter: The Uncovered Stories” or something a lot less cheesy. It’s kinda like Yu-Gi-Oh GX… only a lot less horrible… a lot less…
i love harry
I would most definately buy the manga! I think that it would be alot more interesting seeing it drawn as a manga than reading it or watching a movie…
I would SO get it within less then a billionth of a heartbeat!!! I’m sorry, but I always felt that HP should have been made into a manga ever since I saw my friend’s bro with a Star Wars one, and I’m VERY surprised that one hasn’t come out yet!! T_T As for who should do it, I think that CLAMP would do a very good job at it, since almost all HP fanime and doujinshi sketches give the characters the super-big eyes that’s most recognizable in the shojo-style of Cardcaptors or Sailor Moon. It would break my heart though, if the dudes who did it were the ones who did Naruto (no offense to Naruto lovers (I like it too!), but that style of art wouldn’t do any justice to the HP world).
harry potter manga would be amazing!!!>+< i’d totally buy it
@Tsuki-Chan, I don’t know whether or not JK Rowling is even aware of manga, or if her marketing people are either. She really does need to do something with the HP franchise and I think now is the time to do it before it fizzles from everyone’s memory. Even with the movies still being made, the impact of HP manga would be greater now than later.
i would totally buy HP manga!!!! it’s a fantastic idea!!!! i love harry potter!!!! i hope we would sell the comics!!!!
oie!!!
bem legal !!!
amei =D
beijosss!!!
I think it’s a kickass idea!
But, I think that if a manga gets done on the marauders era first, it’ll be better…
(or it could be like a ‘Get Backers’ thing and include it all in flashbacks -_-)
Coz there’s a LOT we don’t really know bout then, and a lotta areas to fill in.
Regulus Black for one, is a character I would DIE to see…
Well, I’d buy it. The art would have to be good enough, and stay faithful to the appearance of the characters (like not making them into supersexyshojoboys).
There are a LOT of people who love manga and Harry Potter, but then there are also a lot of people who love HP and dislike manga. I’m just not sure how many are in each category.
The artists would have to be careful not to bishie-ify the characters…how long would the manga run, anyway? There’s a thought.
All in all, if handeled well, an HP manga would be awesome.
@DarkAngeKisses, lol “supersexyshojoboys”, bwahahaha, just the thought is kinda creepy yet appealing.
Hmm, you just know JK Rowlings has a ton of ideas she could use for manga. I bet she could fill out many story arcs. She could even have a yaoi line by delving into Dumbledore’s (she did say he was gay) past with what’s his name. Yeah, and then make that the manga where everyone’s bishi and pretty.
This is a fertile medium, so it’s hard to say how long it would run. Maybe for six volumes each arc? Or maybe it never ends but becomes the next Bleach…. I say we pitch the idea to her and see what she says ^^!
I’m french, sorry for the not good englishreader i am >.< I like HPxDm to ! And a manga with they can be a good idea, I want I want ! hurm … sorry. So a said, a find good so an idea ^^ We can make our manga to ! no ? woh make with me ? nobody ? ok XD
HP + Manga = Best way ever to make money. If someone did make a HP Manga, nearly every Harry Potter fan would buy it! Like me! I hope someone does make a Harry Potter manga… in the style of Arina Tanemura! That would be SOO cool!
(\___/)
(=’.'=)
(”)-(”)
I hate it. It draw Snape like a homosexual and Harry looklike an adnormal guy. Hate….hate…hate
i would love to read!!
D
they look so cute already XD
lol I just asked a question about this on Y/A. I love both manga and Harry Potter and I think it’s an awesome idea. I’d buy every one!!!!!
I would freaking die. of happiness. and spend all my grocery/medicine/rent/bills money on them. All of it. And then I would starve happily. Well, maybe not happily, but probably not as miserably as I would have if I hadn’t had it and I just plain starved… O_o
anyway…
I would buy that.
pooblish on da winter net… duh
Get Ken Akamatsu to do it, he made Negima after all, why shouldn’t he try this?
I’m very sorry if this causes you any misery…
But in all honesty Ken Akamatsu writing Harry Potter manga…
I love Negima, this is true.
I am male, this is also true.
I am straight, and would love to see a Harry Potter manga however…
I have never felt the desire to see shots of Hermione in various stages of undress or disrobed when any nearby wizards sneeze.
Akamatsu’s trademark is upskirt shots and scenes of multiple girls taking long hot baths with a male inevitably stumbling into the general vicinity to be pounded on mercilessly. Admittedly the anime of Negima is very tasteful and an HP manga could be written like that, but even then it would become a romantic comedy if it were written by Akamatsu.
Really I think that an HP manga is inevitable given the success of the story in Japan… I really think though that it would need to be created by fans first to show the premise is sound in order to be published.
So what is left is simple, fans must create it first, publish the product free online so publishers may see it… Then wait for a professional publisher to accept the idea and make the appropriate deals to make the thing offical.
In the meantime SOMEBODY has to draw the thing and SOMEBODY has to write a decent adaptation of the stories. By SOMEBODY I mean SOMEONE that might be reading this MIGHT be inspired to actively campaign to create a fanfiction type retelling of the story of Harry Potter in manga form.
If SOMEONE does like the idea I reccomend that SOMEONE take steps IMMEDIATELY to make the idea real. If you build it, it will gather fans, and therefore gather demand. Post it on the HUNDREDS of fan sites once the first portions are complete. The publishers will have to see it because of the sheer volume of sites, once they see a working prototype they will be forced by the dollar signs to make it so.
Basically what I’m saying is if you are reading this and salivating then find somebody who can draw and somebody who can write and START WRITING IMMEDIATELY SO YOU CAN POST THE FINISHED PRODUCT HERE!!!
I am an insane being aren’t I?
NO… I’m sorry… no Some things aren’t meant to be… I’m going to be honest right now. I stopped liking Harry Potter after book 5. Rowling’s writing went really down hill as well as the plot. Much like Twilight, I think Harry Potter (as well as the way people obsess over Voldemort and Snape) is just way too much and it makes these things incredibly over-reated. For us who don’t care as much about the series end up hating it more when screaming fangirls make huge deals over these stupid things. So honestly, no. Harry Potter has been dead since the third movie as well as the books. I’m not looking forward to the rest of the movies, nor did I look forward to finishing the books.
An anime or Manga to finish this off? I daresay. NO! DO NOT WANT!
CLAMP made the Cardcaptors dub..and not many people likes it.SO..i dunnno really.But the Manga Hp’s Looks kinda kewl thought.=P..Go on http://www.sailormoon.com..sign up and chat..and talk to a person named Mercury